By Philip J. Lazarus, NCSP, Florida International University
Shane R. Jimerson, NCSP, University of California, Santa Barbara
Stephen E. Brock, NCSP, California State University, Sacramento
Natural disasters can be especially traumatic for children and
youth. Experiencing a dangerous or violent flood, storm, or earthquake is
frightening even for adults, and the devastation to the familiar environment
(i.e., home and community) can be long lasting and distressing. Often an entire
community is impacted, further undermining a child's sense of security and
normalcy. These factors present a variety of unique issues and coping
challenges, including issues associated with specific types of natural
disasters, the need to relocate when home and/or community have been destroyed,
the role of the family in lessening or exacerbating the trauma, emotional
reactions, and coping techniques.
Children look to the significant adults in their lives for
guidance on how to manage their reactions after the immediate threat is over.
Parents, teachers, and other caregivers can help children and youth cope in the
aftermath of a natural disaster by remaining calm and reassuring children that
they will be all right. Immediate response efforts should emphasize teaching
effective coping strategies, fostering supportive relationships, and helping
children understand their reactions.
Schools can help play an important role is in this process by
providing a stable and familiar environment. Through the support of caring
adults school personnel can help children return to normal activities and
routines (to the extent possible), and provide an opportunity to transform a
frightening event into a learning experience.
Issues Associated With Specific Disasters
Hurricanes. Usually hurricanes are predicted days to
weeks in advance, giving communities time to prepare. These predictions give
families time to gather supplies and prepare. At the same time, however, these
activities may generate fear and anxiety. Although communities can be made aware
of potential danger, there is always uncertainty about the exact location of
where the hurricane will impact. When a hurricane strikes, victims experience
intense thunder, rain, lightning, and wind. Consequently, startle reactions to
sounds may be acute in the months that follow. Among a few children subsequent
storms may trigger panic reactions. Immediate reactions to hurricanes can
include emotional and physical exhaustion. In some instances children may
experience survivor guilt (e.g., that they were not harmed, while others were
injured or killed).
Earthquakes. Aftershocks differentiate earthquakes from
other natural disasters. Since there is no clearly defined endpoint, the
disruptions caused by continued tremors may increase psychological distress.
Unlike other natural disasters (e.g., hurricanes and certain types of floods),
earthquakes occur with virtually no warning. This fact limits the ability of
disaster victims to make the psychological adjustments that can facilitate
coping. This relative lack of predictability also significantly lessens feelings
of control. While one can climb to higher ground during a flood, or install
storm shutters before a hurricane, there is usually no advance warning or
immediate preparation with earthquakes. Survivors may have to cope with
reminders of the destruction (e.g., sounds of explosions, and the rumbling of
aftershocks; smells of toxic fumes and smoke; and tastes of soot, rubber, and
smoke).
Tornadoes. Like earthquakes, tornadoes can bring mass
destruction in a matter of minutes, and individuals typically have little time
to prepare. Confusion and frustration often follow. Similar to a hurricane,
people experience sensations during tornadoes that may generate coping
challenges. It can be difficult to cope with the sights and smells of
destruction. Given the capricious nature of tornadoes, survivor guilt has been
observed to be an especially common coping challenge. For instance, some
children may express guilt that they still have a house to live in while their
friend next door does not.
Floods. These events are one of the most common natural
disasters. Flash floods are the most dangerous as they occur without warning;
move at intense speeds; and can tear out trees, destroy roads and bridges, and
wreck buildings. In cases of dam failure the water can be especially
destructive. Sensations that may generate coping challenges include desolation
of the landscape, the smell of sludge and sodden property, coldness and wetness,
and vast amounts of mud. Most floods do not recede overnight, and many
residents have to wait days or weeks before they can begin the cleanup.
Recovery Can Take Time
Although the natural disasters may only last a short period,
survivors can be involved with the disaster aftermath for months or even years.
Collaboration between the school crisis response team and an assortment of
community, state, and federal organizations and agencies is necessary to respond
to the many needs of children, families, and communities following a natural
disaster. Families are often required to deal with multiple people and agencies
(e.g., insurance adjustors, contractors, electricians, roofers, the Red Cross,
the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), and the Salvation Army). Healing
in the aftermath of a natural disaster takes time; however, advanced preparation
and immediate response will facilitate subsequent coping and healing.
Possible Reactions of Children and Youth to Natural Disasters
The severity of children's reactions will depend on their
specific risk factors. These include exposure to the actual event, personal
injury or loss of a loved one, level of parental support, dislocation from their
home or community, the level of physical destruction, and pre-existing risks,
such as a previous traumatic experience or mental illness. Adults should
contact a professional if children exhibit significant changes in behavior or
any of the following symptoms over an extended period of time.
-
Preschoolers-thumb sucking, bedwetting, clinging to
parents, sleep disturbances, loss of appetite, fear of the dark, regression in
behavior, and withdrawal from friends and routines.
-
Elementary School Children-irritability,
aggressiveness, clinginess, nightmares, school avoidance, poor concentration,
and withdrawal from activities and friends.
-
Adolescents-sleeping and eating disturbances,
agitation, increase in conflicts, physical complaints, delinquent behavior,
and poor concentration.
A minority of children may be at risk of post-traumatic stress
disorder (PTSD). Symptoms can include those listed above as well as
re-experiencing the disaster during play and/or dreams; anticipating or feeling
that the disaster is happening again; avoiding reminders of the disaster;
general numbness to emotional topics; and increased arousal symptoms such as
inability to concentrate and startle reactions. Although rare, some adolescents
may also be at increased risk of suicide if they suffer from serious mental
health problems like PTSD or depression. Again, adults should seek professional
mental health help for children exhibiting these symptoms.
Immediately Following a Natural Disaster: Information for
Parents and Teachers
Remain calm and reassuring. Children take their cues from
you, especially young children. Acknowledge the loss or destruction, but
emphasize the community's efforts to cleanup and rebuild. To the extent it is
possible to do so, assure them that family and friends will take care of them
and that life will return to normal.
Acknowledge and normalize their feelings. Allow children
to discuss their feelings and concerns, and address any questions they may have
regarding the event. Listen and empathize. An empathetic listener is very
important. Let them know that their reactions are normal and expected.
Encourage children to talk about disaster-related events.
Children need an opportunity to discuss their experiences in a safe, accepting
environment. Provide activities that enable children to discuss their
experiences. This may include a range of methods (both verbal and nonverbal) and
incorporate varying projects (e.g., drawing, stories, music, drama, audio and
video recording). Seek the help of the school psychologist, counselor, or social
worker if you need help with ideas or managing the conversation.
Promote positive coping and problem-solving skills.
Activities should teach children how to apply problem-solving skills to
disaster-related stressors. Encourage children to develop realistic and
positive methods of coping that increase their ability to manage their anxiety
and to identify which strategies fit with each situation.
Emphasize children's resiliency. Focus on their
competencies. Help children identify what they have done in the past that helped
them cope when they were frightened or upset. Bring their attention to other
communities that have experienced natural disasters and recovered (e.g., Miami,
FL and Charleston, SC).
Strengthen children's friendship and peer support.
Children with strong emotional support from others are better able to cope with
adversity. Children's relationships with peers can provide suggestions for how
to cope and can help decrease isolation. In many disaster situations,
friendships may be disrupted because of family relocations. In some cases,
parents may be less available to provide support to their children because of
their own distress and feelings of being overwhelmed. Activities such as asking
children to work cooperatively in small groups can help children strengthen
supportive relationships with their peers.
Take care of your own needs. Take time for yourself and
try to deal with your own reactions to the situation as fully as possible. You
will be better able to help your children if you are coping well. If you are
anxious or upset, your children are more likely to feel the same way. Talk to
other adults such as family, friends, faith leaders, or counselors. It is
important not to dwell on your fears or anxiety by yourself. Sharing feelings
with others often makes people feel more connected and secure. Take care of your
physical health. Make time, however small, to do things you enjoy. Avoid
using drugs or alcohol to feel better.
Immediately Following a Natural Disaster: Specific Information
for Schools
Identify children and youth who are high risk and plan
interventions. Risk factors are outlined in the above section on children's
reactions. Interventions may include classroom discussions, individual
counseling, small group counseling, or family therapy. From classroom
discussions, and by maintaining close contact with teachers and parents, the
school crisis response team can help determine which students need counseling
services. A mechanism also needs to be in place for self-referral and
parent-referral of students.
Provide time for students to discuss the disaster.
Depending on the situation, teachers may be able to guide this discussion in
class, or students can meet with the school psychologist or other mental health
professional for a group crisis intervention. Classroom discussions help
children to make some sense of the disaster. They also encourage students to
develop effective means of coping, discover that their classmates share similar
questions, and develop peer support networks. Teachers should not be expected
to conduct such discussions if children are severely impacted or if they
themselves are distressed.
Allow time for staff to discuss their feelings and share
their experiences. Members of your crisis team should also have the
opportunity to receive support from a trained mental health professional.
Providing crisis intervention is emotionally draining and caregivers will need
an opportunity to process their crisis response. This could include teachers and
other school staff if they have been serving as crisis caregivers for students.
Secure additional mental health support. Although many
caregivers are often willing to provide support during the immediate aftermath
of a natural disaster, long-term services may be lacking. School mental health
professionals can help provide and coordinate mental health services, but it is
important to connect with community resources as well in order to provide such
long-term assistance. Ideally these relationships would be established in
advance.
Helping Children Adjust to Relocation After a Natural Disaster
The frequent need to relocate after a disaster creates unique
coping challenges. It may contribute to the social, environmental, and
psychological stress experienced by children and their families. Children will
be most impacted by the reactions of their parents and other family members, the
duration of the relocation, their natural coping style and emotional reactivity,
and their ability to stay connected with friends and other familiar people and
activities. To the extent possible parents and other caregivers should:
-
Provide opportunities for children to see friends.
-
Bring personal items that the child values when staying in
temporary housing.
-
Establish some daily routines so that the child is able to
have a sense of what to expect (including returning to school as soon as
possible).
-
Provide opportunities for children to share their ideas and
listen carefully to their concerns or fears.
-
Be sensitive to the disruption that relocation may cause and
be responsive to the child's needs.
-
Consider the developmental level and unique experiences of
each child; it is important to remember that as children vary, so will their
responses to the disruption of relocation,
In addition, school personnel should:
-
Determine the status of every child in the school. Contact
each child who is absent and keep a record. Identify the needs of children
whose home was destroyed or damaged.
-
Find out the phone numbers and addresses of every student that
had to relocate. Encourage classmates to write notes or make phone calls.
-
Develop an advisory committee of students to report back to
school staff about what resources and changes in routines will help students
cope.
-
Listen to and observe students' behavior. It takes time for
children to understand and adjust to disasters. It is perfectly normal for
them to discuss the event over and over again. Provide opportunities for
children to discuss how they are coping. Use creative arts (e.g., drama, art,
music, photography) to help them express their emotions.
-
Help connect families to community resources. Bring agencies
into the school that can deal with needs related to housing, finances, and
insurance. Ensure that children get any necessary medical and emotional
assistance.
-
Increase staffing for before and after school care. If
possible, extend the service for additional hours and even on weekends.
-
Incorporate information about the disaster into related
subject areas, as appropriate. Science, math, history, and language arts are
especially relevant.
Adapted from Lazarus, P. J., & Jimerson, S. R., Brock, S. E.
(2002). Natural Disasters. In S. E. Brock, P. J. Lazarus, & S. R. Jimerson
(Eds.), Best Practices in School Crisis Prevention and Intervention (pp.
435-450), Bethesda, MD: National Association of School Psychologists and other
crisis information posted on the NASP website at
www.nasponline.org.